Criteria for Poster Judging
Below are the criteria that will be
used in the poster judging competition:
-
Student presenters will have a maximum
of 10 minutes with the judges during which time they should
give a concise presentation of their work to the judge or judges (3-4
minutes maximum) which will be followed by 6-7 minutes of questions
about the work.
-
In round one, each poster will be
viewed by only one judge, randomly selected, but not from their
institute. Each judge views 5 posters.
-
Judges confer and select one of the
viewed posters for round 2. In case a judge can't decide, a second
judge may be sent to view two closely ranked
posters.
-
Students need to be available in case
they are selected for round 2 (Posters will be identified soon after
the end of round one with post it notes).
-
During round 2, posters selected in
round 1 will be viewed twice, by two pairs of judges, again for 10
minutes each as outlined above and given a score. Prizes will be
awarded based on overall score from the 4 judges in round
2.
-
In some cases, judges will again need
to go back to posters to re-evaluate two closely ranked posters.
Therefore, students are asked to keep close to their posters for the
duration of the judging process and may be asked to present 3 or even 4
times.
-
Posters are judged on scientific
excellence, ability of student to present and answer questions, scope
of research, taking into consideration the length of time in the
program and the proportion of research contributed directly by the
student.
|